I meant to say also that it doesn't matter why it leaks, we will still replace it if less than 12 months old. But we will only replace it once. So if you know you are going to have a problem with water quality or high pressure, you can instead ask for a credit towards the purchase of a CSV1A valve. There is always a trade off however. Because you can replace the plastic valve about three times for the price of a CSV1A. Kind of depends on how long the plastic valves last in your application.
I have a plastic valve that has been working for 16 years. Of course it is installed inside the well casing so a small leak is never noticed.