5
« on: October 17, 2011, 08:02:42 AM »
I am going to start with your first statement and that was the problem started when the check valve was installed. Multiple check valves tend to work against each other and water hammer is one of the symptoms of that. My first suggestion is going to be to remove (or drill a hole through)that newest check valve. Your pump coming out of that storage tank has a check valve or foot valve on it. You do not need more than one (although that has been a common myth for some time).
And as you can see, it is a false sense of security counting on that storage tank to be full when your pump quits you. It could just as well be empty. We do however make a product called the Cycle Sensor that would turn off your booster pump when the storage tank ran dry. At least protecting your booster pump from that early death.
And now that you understand that stored water is not always available when you need it, you could eliminate a large amount of frustration by losing that storage tank. I understand your concern about being without water when your pump is out because I also work from a water well at my house but two pump is twice the trouble and if we add a Cycle Stop Valve to your 2HP submersible, we can make it last as long as possible either way.
The pressure relief valve and the expansion tank are safety features and your plumber did you a service making sure those were installed correctly. The pressure relief valve will open if your pressure switch fails to turn off your pump and pressure builds higher than it is set to hold thus keeping you from blowing up a pressure tank or line. Hopefully it is not set higher than the pressure your pump can build? That is the only catch with that product.
Lets start by getting rid of that additional check and see if that solves the water hammer problem. If you decide to keep the storage tank..you will need a CS1PH1-2HP Cycle Sensor to keep you safe if the storage tank runs dry.
If you keep the two pump system, we can also add a Cycle Stop valve to your jet pump so that it comes on and stays on and softens the starts and stops of your water pump thus taking all of the surge/water hammer out of the rest of the system.
Hope this is a start to getting your water system where you do not have to think about it but every 15 or so years!!